City Island, NY Real Estate

City Island NY Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







City Island NY Real Estate Stats

Average Price in City Island: $535,000 / County Average: $708,598

Average Taxes in City Island: $5,450 / County Average: $4,854

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in City Island: $323 / County Average: $439

Average Walkscore in City Island: 67 / County Average: 83

Average Year Built in City Island: 1950 / County Average: 1948

Average Days on Website in City Island: 289 / County Average: 83

City Island NY Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhood in City Island NY


Areas in City Island NY


Listings in City Island

taxes do not reflect the nys star tax exemption. call today to live the City Island lifestyle!...

Courtesy of: Century 21 Marciano

a private gated, waterfront community located in the sought after area of City Island offering great restaurants, shopping and outdoor recreation. this light filled home f...

Courtesy of: William Raveis Real Estate

taxes do not reflect the nys star school tax exemption of $1,440 per year. call today to live the City Island lifestyle!...

Courtesy of: Century 21 Marciano

Tifully maintained legal 2 family in the heart of City Island. quiet block steps from nyc express bus, grocer...

Courtesy of: Houlihan Lawrence Inc.

Located right in the heart of City Island you will find this unassuming stunning income producer with loads of curb appeal...

Courtesy of: R New York

5 bath condo at the boatyard condominiums, a 24 hr gated waterfront community on City Island. the entry foyer leads upstairs to a beautiful and spacious living ...

Courtesy of: Keller Williams Realty Elite

brand new everything from boiler to baths. huge driveway and great backyard! near the City Island nautical museum and fabulous restaurants. move in ready. separate meters. quality workmanship throughout. no flood insurance,...

Courtesy of: Keller Williams Realty Group

you are a quick commute by express bus to midtown manhattan, and near City Island's many celebrated restaurants, shops, and parks. resort style living! a must see!...

Courtesy of: Compass Greater NY, LLC

this charming home is in true move-in condition on City Island. the large living room has windows on two side to allow for maximum natural sunligh...

Courtesy of: Howard Hanna Rand Realty

it's conveniently located in the pelham parkway section of the bronx near white plains road business district with access to irt #2/#5 /bxm11 (midtown), beeline 60, 61, 62 and bx 39, 12 and 22/new york botanical garden/bronx zoo and 15mins driving distance to orchard beach and City Island. also, there are nearby stores, restaurants, banks, pharmacies, post office, gym, supermarket, and a park that has a new dog park, 2 playgrounds, basketball court and handball court. multiple parking options; including street, indoor garages & municipal parking lot within the surrounding ...

Courtesy of: Diamond Quality Real Estate

located just steps from excellent restaurants and quaint neighborhood shops on City Island avenue. a great buy!...

Courtesy of: Today Realty Corp.

various bus stops minutes away. close proximity to City Island and orchard beach to enjoy a beach day, seafood lunches and or a day of fishing. a wonderful suburban neighborhood feel with water views, various deli's, bronx pizza and located in nyc. this particular home has a first floor of 3br, 1ba (viking appliacnes), second floor 3br, 1ba, over a finished basement. all apartments have been finished with brazilian flooring featuring custom edging, custom moldings, doors, custom fi...

Courtesy of: Houlihan Lawrence Inc.

once work is done, you are on vacation 365 days a year.this and so much more - is making City Island living the best kept secret of new york city.additional features:2-car garageprivate 2-car drivewaymanicured garden with auto-sprinkler system2021 upgraded central hvac (forced air ac & heat).baseboard radiators throughout2021 upgraded electric2019 chef‘s kitchen; wolf gas range & sub-zero fridge hardwood floors throughoutrecessed custom lighting with dimmerswood burning fireplacealarmexempt of flood insuranceonly $7500 annual taxestake the opportunity to watch the included video, it "walks" you through the entire property. showings by appointment only, kindly contact listing broker directly with any questions and to set up a showing....

Courtesy of: R New York

Ready for something new and unexpected? live in new york city but with beaches, yacht clubs, 15 seafood restaurants, golf courses, horseback riding, swimming, kayaking, biking & running trails in as little as 20 minutes from manhattan!City Island the most unique, undiscovered place to live in new york city. truly the best kept secret just north/east of manhattan is this island with very easy access to manhattan by car or mta. it is the only place i know in new york city that feels like vacation 24/7-365.this 1100 square foot condo with its unique imprint of its percussionist owner can easily transform to a contemporary home or your personal style by a simple change of paint color. imagine li...

Courtesy of: R New York

within five minutes to several private beach/pool clubs and five minutes to City Island. low hoa fee @ $325/month....

Courtesy of: Realty Connect USA LLC

features living room, donning room open floor concept, 1 full bathroom, in the heart of City Island. hardwood flooring throughout and ac allowed. ...

Courtesy of: Realty One Group Dynasty

close proximity to public transportation, major highways, beach and all of your City Island dining and shopping needs. agents bring your buyers. a pleasure to show....

Courtesy of: RE/MAX Distinguished Hms.&Prop

Ls like this do not come around often! but that's City Island, a rare treasure indeed! t...

Courtesy of: Houlihan Lawrence Inc.

it is conveniently located to many restaurants, public transportation, stores, schools, etc. a short ride to City Island, bay plaza mall and orchard beach. monthly maintenance $1,348.46 a month. no pets. 382 shares...

Courtesy of: RE/MAX City Square

even better traveling and access due to the new City Island ferry!...

Courtesy of: Cohen and Cohen Consulting

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Location & Address

Nicole Morris
Cell: 347-444-1183